Pacific island relocation plans ignore culture, putting climate adaptation at risk
Fiji and Vanuatu have built comprehensive climate relocation policies, but analysis reveals they systematically undervalue cultural tradition, customary governance, and community identity—potentially undermining their own effectiveness. For policymakers and development organizations, the finding signals that technically sound relocation frameworks fail without indigenous cultural integration.
Originaltitel: Tradition is inadequately incorporated within relocation policy: Insights from Fiji and Vanuatu
<p>Culturally-appropriate planned relocation policies are critical to enabling climate adaptation, particularly in the Pacific and Indian Oceans where rising sea levels and intensifying hazards threaten communities. Fiji and Vanuatu are frequently cited as international leaders in relocation policy, yet there has been limited critical analysis of the effectiveness and comprehensiveness of their policy frameworks. We analysed 27 institutional instruments guiding climate-induced relocation and displacement in Fiji and Vanuatu and assessed each instrument's contribution to community resilience across three dimensions: means, equity, and tradition. While both countries have developed a suite of policies that collectively support relocation, tradition - encompassing cultural heritage, attachment to place, and customary governance - is underrepresented. Successful relocation policy requires the integration of cultural and traditional dimensions alongside material and procedural considerations, particularly in Indigenous contexts where culture, identity and land are intertwined. Strengthening internal policy design capacity and fostering cross-sectoral integration will contribute to just, sustainable, and culturally-grounded relocation processes and outcomes. Insights from Fiji and Vanuatu offer valuable lessons for other nations developing culturally-inclusive relocation policy in response to climate risks.</p>